Because your comment got pruned along with mine, let me repost it so that I can still reply to it, even though it'll live but a few brief moments before likely being flagged: >>It's an incredibly credible comment. >reenorap, and HN in general, is not on my list of credible people to take medical advice from. >>might have an independent mind and (gasp) believe their own lying eyes >Yes, look at me, holding doctors above LLMs when it comes to medical advice. I'm basically brainwashed. >You know what, I'm being enlightened. Engineers are sometimes wrong. Right? So, we should get LLMs to design bridges, airplanes, etc. We could get some layperson to google it after for verification." Here, I'll quote the relevant part of my comment that your inanity ignored: >if you have a need to have slavish trust in authority, be it LLMs or MDs I'll restate this for you: If you blindly believe what anyone or any thing says on the basis purely of authority, be that a pedigree or technological idolatry, you've demonstrated that you are unfit to self-govern. It's absolutely astounding how a nominally educated society can have all the pieces of literacy and critical thinking yet stubbornly refuse to assemble them into any kind of coherent ability to consider or evaluate inputs independently. You can't even read a two-line comment with any degree of accuracy! Look to the beam in your own eye! LLMs are median prediction engines. They transform what they're given into a given continuance of what they've been exposed to before. That's it. It's a giant correlative database. There's no man behind the curtain, just a training corpus. They're not malicious, nor magical. If you use it like it's a mind reader ("I have this rash on my body"), yeah, you're going to get a generic (and wrong)/response because you're receiving the input of a zone of high potential with no actual information (i.e. you're an being mirrored+system prompts). What rash? Where? How long has it been there? How big is it? The color? What correlative events have occurred? Have you taken any new medications or supplements? Etc. etc. The problem isn't LLMs. The problem is you're all unable to think for yourselves. Even if you could wave a magic wand and make LLMs disappear, you'd all just find new idols to blindly follow instead of using the brain and consciousness evolution so helpfully provided you to escape this exact problem of evaluating hearsay. Of course, you and every other dissenting reader won't take this to heart or even really read it. You'll skim it, pretend that's the same thing, look for the no-no words, hammer your keyboard, confabulate a response to something no one actually said, then pat yourself on the back for having slapped down yet another hand reaching out to lift you out of your own ignorance.
 Top